Non-Partisan Systemic Audit Disclaimer: This report card evaluates the First-Past-The-Post electoral system itself, not the political parties or candidates who ran under it. We audit how accurately voter intent translated into seats and law-making authority using an objective 100-point rubric.

BC 2026 Election Report Card

Electoral System Performance & Representation Audit

Standard Form: FPTP-BC-93
System Audited: First-Past-The-Post (FPTP)
Election Year: 2026 General Election
Auditor: The British Columbia Electorate
Scope of Audit: All 93 Provincial Districts
Evaluation Criterion Audit Finding & Observation Points Mathematical Basis
Local District Consent
Winners with 50% or more voter support
In (), the MLA won with a minority of votes. The democratic majority of local neighbours explicitly voted for someone else. / 35.0
Proportional Caucus Share
Popular vote share vs. seats won
The system shifted of seats away from direct voter choice. The leading party received an unearned bonus, while third and distributed parties were underrepresented. / 35.0 1 pt deducted per 1% seat skew
Legislative Power Alignment
Law-making monopoly vs. citizen consent
100% unilateral authority to pass legislation was granted on a minority vote, representing an unearned power bonus of above voter consent. / 30.0
F FINAL GRADE
Overall Democratic Performance:

Failing Democratic Standard

Composite Score (Out of 100)
/ 100

The 100-Point Audit Rubric:

  • 1. Local District Consent (35 Points Max): Each single-member district represents an equal share of the province (35 / 93 ≈ 0.38 pts per riding). When an MLA achieves 50% or more of the vote, the district earns full points. When an MLA holds under 50%, the district receives zero points because more local constituents rejected the winner than endorsed them.
  • 2. Proportional Caucus Share (35 Points Max): Uses the internationally recognized Loosemore-Hanby Disproportionality Index (D), calculated as half the sum of absolute differences between each party's popular vote share and seat share across all parties. Points = 35 minus the Loosemore-Hanby Index (minimum 0).
  • 3. Legislative Power Alignment (30 Points Max): If a party forms a minority government (no unilateral monopoly) or wins 50% or more of the popular vote, all 30 points are awarded. If a single party wins a manufactured majority with less than 50% of the vote, 2 points are deducted for every 1% of the population excluded from the governing mandate: 30 - (50% - Vote Share %) × 2.
  • Wrong Winner Anomaly Override: If the party winning the most seats received fewer popular votes than another party, the composite score is automatically capped at 45/100 (Grade F).
Grading Scale Reference:
A = 90 - 100 pts (Proportional)
C = 70 - 79 pts (Distorted)
B = 80 - 89 pts (Fair)
D = 60 - 69 pts (Severe Skew)
FAIL = 59 pts and below (Unbalanced Mandate)
Audit Ledger Verification:
Total Valid Ridings Audited: 93
Majority Control Threshold: 47 Seats (50.5%)
Legislative Control: 100% Power Awarded on Plurality

The Three Stages of Power: Votes → Seats → Power

Visualizing how voter intent is warped into an artificial 100% governing monopoly.

Stage 1: Popular Vote %
What Citizens Voted
True provincial voter intent
Stage 2: Seat Share %
What FPTP Awarded
Distorted seat distribution
Stage 3: Law-Making Power %
100% Governing Power
Total law-making monopoly

Individual District Transcripts (93 Ridings)

Examining the winner's support vs. the combined opposition in every constituency.

Policy Recommendation

Replacing First-Past-The-Post with Proportional Representation

Under Proportional Representation, if a party earns 40% of the popular vote, they receive 40% of the seats. Unilateral 100% legislative control requires 50%+ consensus, ending manufactured false majorities.